Pravni položaj vozača u Uber sistemu prevoza putnika
The legal position of driver in the Uber transport of passengers
Abstract
U radu se razmatra pravni položaj vozača u odnosu na korisnika usluge prevoza, ali i spram uber-a, kao organizatora tržišta prevoza i samog prevozioca, odnosno špeditera. Vozačev položaj je u velikoj meri određen pravnom prirodom uber-ovog položaja po principu mehanizma "klackalice" - ako je uber posrednik, onda je vozač prevozilac, i suprotno - ako je uber prevozilac, onda je vozač njegov pomoćnik. Takođe, ako se vozač odredi kao prevozilac, onda je nejasno da li je on javni ili privatni prevozilac, imajući u vidu (ne)određenost kruga korisnika usluge prevoza. U prvom delu rada je prikazan uticaj ekonomije deljenja i tehničkog napretka na stvaranje novih oblika prevoza. Zatim je ukazano na pravni problem novog načina organizovanja usluge prevoza, kao i pravne kvalifikacije osnovnih lica u njemu (pre svega, vozača i uber-a, ali i korisnika kao potrošača). Najzad, na kraju se u okviru zaključka vozač određuje prevoziočevim pomoćnikom, dok se njegov položaj zaposlenog kod prevozioca i da...lje čini spornim.
In the article, the author considers a legal position of a driver in relation to a transport service user and in relation to uber as a transport market maker and transporter, respectively freight forwarder. The driver's role in the uber system is largely determined with the legal nature of Uber's legal position by the principle of the seesaw toy. If uber has an intermediary role, then driver is a carrier, and vice versa, if uber has been deemed a carrier, then a driver has a role as a carrier's assistant. Also, if a driver has been considered as a carrier, then it is unclear whether he is a public or only a private carrier, having in mind an (in)definite number of users. In the first chapter of the article, the author explains the impact of the sharing economy and technical progress on creating a new mode of transport. Furthermore, the legal problem of the new way of providing a transport service has been highlighted, as well as a legal qualification of subjects involved in Uber's busi...ness structure. Finally, the author concludes that a driver should be deemed as a carrier's assistant, having in mind that uber as a carrier and as the organizer of the transport market has a decisive influence on the whole process of transporting a passenger (from the beginning phase to ending).
Keywords:
Vozač / Uber / Prevozilac / Posrednik u prevozu / Pomoćnik / (Ne)javni prevozilac / Uber / Transport Intermediary / Driver / Carrier / Assistant / (Non)public CarrierSource:
Pravo i privreda, 2020, 58, 3, 201-219Publisher:
- Udruženje pravnika u privredi Srbije, Beograd
Funding / projects:
- Projekat Pravnog fakulteta Univerziteta u Beogradu: Identitetski preobražaj Srbije
Collections
Institution/Community
Pravni fakultet / Faculty of Law University of BelgradeTY - JOUR AU - Janković, Svetislav PY - 2020 UR - https://ralf.ius.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/1205 AB - U radu se razmatra pravni položaj vozača u odnosu na korisnika usluge prevoza, ali i spram uber-a, kao organizatora tržišta prevoza i samog prevozioca, odnosno špeditera. Vozačev položaj je u velikoj meri određen pravnom prirodom uber-ovog položaja po principu mehanizma "klackalice" - ako je uber posrednik, onda je vozač prevozilac, i suprotno - ako je uber prevozilac, onda je vozač njegov pomoćnik. Takođe, ako se vozač odredi kao prevozilac, onda je nejasno da li je on javni ili privatni prevozilac, imajući u vidu (ne)određenost kruga korisnika usluge prevoza. U prvom delu rada je prikazan uticaj ekonomije deljenja i tehničkog napretka na stvaranje novih oblika prevoza. Zatim je ukazano na pravni problem novog načina organizovanja usluge prevoza, kao i pravne kvalifikacije osnovnih lica u njemu (pre svega, vozača i uber-a, ali i korisnika kao potrošača). Najzad, na kraju se u okviru zaključka vozač određuje prevoziočevim pomoćnikom, dok se njegov položaj zaposlenog kod prevozioca i dalje čini spornim. AB - In the article, the author considers a legal position of a driver in relation to a transport service user and in relation to uber as a transport market maker and transporter, respectively freight forwarder. The driver's role in the uber system is largely determined with the legal nature of Uber's legal position by the principle of the seesaw toy. If uber has an intermediary role, then driver is a carrier, and vice versa, if uber has been deemed a carrier, then a driver has a role as a carrier's assistant. Also, if a driver has been considered as a carrier, then it is unclear whether he is a public or only a private carrier, having in mind an (in)definite number of users. In the first chapter of the article, the author explains the impact of the sharing economy and technical progress on creating a new mode of transport. Furthermore, the legal problem of the new way of providing a transport service has been highlighted, as well as a legal qualification of subjects involved in Uber's business structure. Finally, the author concludes that a driver should be deemed as a carrier's assistant, having in mind that uber as a carrier and as the organizer of the transport market has a decisive influence on the whole process of transporting a passenger (from the beginning phase to ending). PB - Udruženje pravnika u privredi Srbije, Beograd T2 - Pravo i privreda T1 - Pravni položaj vozača u Uber sistemu prevoza putnika T1 - The legal position of driver in the Uber transport of passengers EP - 219 IS - 3 SP - 201 VL - 58 DO - 10.5937/PiP2003201J UR - conv_2329 ER -
@article{ author = "Janković, Svetislav", year = "2020", abstract = "U radu se razmatra pravni položaj vozača u odnosu na korisnika usluge prevoza, ali i spram uber-a, kao organizatora tržišta prevoza i samog prevozioca, odnosno špeditera. Vozačev položaj je u velikoj meri određen pravnom prirodom uber-ovog položaja po principu mehanizma "klackalice" - ako je uber posrednik, onda je vozač prevozilac, i suprotno - ako je uber prevozilac, onda je vozač njegov pomoćnik. Takođe, ako se vozač odredi kao prevozilac, onda je nejasno da li je on javni ili privatni prevozilac, imajući u vidu (ne)određenost kruga korisnika usluge prevoza. U prvom delu rada je prikazan uticaj ekonomije deljenja i tehničkog napretka na stvaranje novih oblika prevoza. Zatim je ukazano na pravni problem novog načina organizovanja usluge prevoza, kao i pravne kvalifikacije osnovnih lica u njemu (pre svega, vozača i uber-a, ali i korisnika kao potrošača). Najzad, na kraju se u okviru zaključka vozač određuje prevoziočevim pomoćnikom, dok se njegov položaj zaposlenog kod prevozioca i dalje čini spornim., In the article, the author considers a legal position of a driver in relation to a transport service user and in relation to uber as a transport market maker and transporter, respectively freight forwarder. The driver's role in the uber system is largely determined with the legal nature of Uber's legal position by the principle of the seesaw toy. If uber has an intermediary role, then driver is a carrier, and vice versa, if uber has been deemed a carrier, then a driver has a role as a carrier's assistant. Also, if a driver has been considered as a carrier, then it is unclear whether he is a public or only a private carrier, having in mind an (in)definite number of users. In the first chapter of the article, the author explains the impact of the sharing economy and technical progress on creating a new mode of transport. Furthermore, the legal problem of the new way of providing a transport service has been highlighted, as well as a legal qualification of subjects involved in Uber's business structure. Finally, the author concludes that a driver should be deemed as a carrier's assistant, having in mind that uber as a carrier and as the organizer of the transport market has a decisive influence on the whole process of transporting a passenger (from the beginning phase to ending).", publisher = "Udruženje pravnika u privredi Srbije, Beograd", journal = "Pravo i privreda", title = "Pravni položaj vozača u Uber sistemu prevoza putnika, The legal position of driver in the Uber transport of passengers", pages = "219-201", number = "3", volume = "58", doi = "10.5937/PiP2003201J", url = "conv_2329" }
Janković, S.. (2020). Pravni položaj vozača u Uber sistemu prevoza putnika. in Pravo i privreda Udruženje pravnika u privredi Srbije, Beograd., 58(3), 201-219. https://doi.org/10.5937/PiP2003201J conv_2329
Janković S. Pravni položaj vozača u Uber sistemu prevoza putnika. in Pravo i privreda. 2020;58(3):201-219. doi:10.5937/PiP2003201J conv_2329 .
Janković, Svetislav, "Pravni položaj vozača u Uber sistemu prevoza putnika" in Pravo i privreda, 58, no. 3 (2020):201-219, https://doi.org/10.5937/PiP2003201J ., conv_2329 .