Specifičnosti imovinske odgovornosti za štetu od izlivanja/izbacivanja nafte sa broda u vodu
Some specific aspects of the civil liability for discharge and spill the oil from the ships
Abstract
Ovaj rad se bavi specifičnostima koje postoje u pravu naknade šteta usled izazivanja naftnih mrlja od 'brodova'u plovidbi uopšte (kako pomorskoj, tako i rečnoj, kanalskoj i jezerskoj). Specifičnosti ove odgovornosti se posmatraju, uglavnom, spram klasične odgovornosti u plovidbenom pravu. Ovde su posebno izdvojene razlike u pogledu osnova odgovornosti, subjekta odgovornosti, instituta obaveznog osiguranja od odgovornosti, kao i samog međunarodnog obeštećujućeg fonda. Cilj rada je da pokaže neke postojeće nelogičnosti u sistemu stvorenom međunarodnim konvencijama i njihovom primenom od strane država. Naročita pažnja je posvećena predlozima za poboljšanje postojećeg sistema i to kako kroz predloge de lege ferenda promene trenutnog pravnog režima, tako i kroz predloge sudskoj i arbitražnoj praksi u smislu kreativnijeg tumačenja pozitivnih pravila.
This work deals with some specific aspects of civil liability regarding the oil accident caused by discharge and spill of oil by seas and inlands ships. The main idea of the author in this paper is to try to explain and prove the genuine legal nature of (strict) civil liability for the oil accident caused by commercial ships. Although the Convention regime stipulated that only shipowner has had responsibility for oil accident, the author' opinion for this issue is opposite. He has considered that besides shipowner, the liability person should be the operator of the ship. The reason for this viewpoint is found in fact that operator has possession of the ship (and, also of the cargo oil) and therefore he has to bear liability' burden. The author concludes that although the operator is not registered owner of the ship, he has real possibility to manage with ship and to influences to increased and decreased of transport' risks. At the end of the work, it would be explained the role of the ...International Compensation Fund in the case of oil accident.
Keywords:
vlasnik broda / objektivna odgovornost / obavezno osiguranje od odgovornosti / Međunarodni obeštećujući fond / brodar / strict civil liability / shipowner / operator / International Compensation FundSource:
Pravo i privreda, 2012, 49, 10-12, 52-71Publisher:
- Udruženje pravnika u privredi Srbije, Beograd
Collections
Institution/Community
Pravni fakultet / Faculty of Law University of BelgradeTY - JOUR AU - Janković, Svetislav PY - 2012 UR - https://ralf.ius.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/661 AB - Ovaj rad se bavi specifičnostima koje postoje u pravu naknade šteta usled izazivanja naftnih mrlja od 'brodova'u plovidbi uopšte (kako pomorskoj, tako i rečnoj, kanalskoj i jezerskoj). Specifičnosti ove odgovornosti se posmatraju, uglavnom, spram klasične odgovornosti u plovidbenom pravu. Ovde su posebno izdvojene razlike u pogledu osnova odgovornosti, subjekta odgovornosti, instituta obaveznog osiguranja od odgovornosti, kao i samog međunarodnog obeštećujućeg fonda. Cilj rada je da pokaže neke postojeće nelogičnosti u sistemu stvorenom međunarodnim konvencijama i njihovom primenom od strane država. Naročita pažnja je posvećena predlozima za poboljšanje postojećeg sistema i to kako kroz predloge de lege ferenda promene trenutnog pravnog režima, tako i kroz predloge sudskoj i arbitražnoj praksi u smislu kreativnijeg tumačenja pozitivnih pravila. AB - This work deals with some specific aspects of civil liability regarding the oil accident caused by discharge and spill of oil by seas and inlands ships. The main idea of the author in this paper is to try to explain and prove the genuine legal nature of (strict) civil liability for the oil accident caused by commercial ships. Although the Convention regime stipulated that only shipowner has had responsibility for oil accident, the author' opinion for this issue is opposite. He has considered that besides shipowner, the liability person should be the operator of the ship. The reason for this viewpoint is found in fact that operator has possession of the ship (and, also of the cargo oil) and therefore he has to bear liability' burden. The author concludes that although the operator is not registered owner of the ship, he has real possibility to manage with ship and to influences to increased and decreased of transport' risks. At the end of the work, it would be explained the role of the International Compensation Fund in the case of oil accident. PB - Udruženje pravnika u privredi Srbije, Beograd T2 - Pravo i privreda T1 - Specifičnosti imovinske odgovornosti za štetu od izlivanja/izbacivanja nafte sa broda u vodu T1 - Some specific aspects of the civil liability for discharge and spill the oil from the ships EP - 71 IS - 10-12 SP - 52 VL - 49 UR - conv_2082 ER -
@article{ author = "Janković, Svetislav", year = "2012", abstract = "Ovaj rad se bavi specifičnostima koje postoje u pravu naknade šteta usled izazivanja naftnih mrlja od 'brodova'u plovidbi uopšte (kako pomorskoj, tako i rečnoj, kanalskoj i jezerskoj). Specifičnosti ove odgovornosti se posmatraju, uglavnom, spram klasične odgovornosti u plovidbenom pravu. Ovde su posebno izdvojene razlike u pogledu osnova odgovornosti, subjekta odgovornosti, instituta obaveznog osiguranja od odgovornosti, kao i samog međunarodnog obeštećujućeg fonda. Cilj rada je da pokaže neke postojeće nelogičnosti u sistemu stvorenom međunarodnim konvencijama i njihovom primenom od strane država. Naročita pažnja je posvećena predlozima za poboljšanje postojećeg sistema i to kako kroz predloge de lege ferenda promene trenutnog pravnog režima, tako i kroz predloge sudskoj i arbitražnoj praksi u smislu kreativnijeg tumačenja pozitivnih pravila., This work deals with some specific aspects of civil liability regarding the oil accident caused by discharge and spill of oil by seas and inlands ships. The main idea of the author in this paper is to try to explain and prove the genuine legal nature of (strict) civil liability for the oil accident caused by commercial ships. Although the Convention regime stipulated that only shipowner has had responsibility for oil accident, the author' opinion for this issue is opposite. He has considered that besides shipowner, the liability person should be the operator of the ship. The reason for this viewpoint is found in fact that operator has possession of the ship (and, also of the cargo oil) and therefore he has to bear liability' burden. The author concludes that although the operator is not registered owner of the ship, he has real possibility to manage with ship and to influences to increased and decreased of transport' risks. At the end of the work, it would be explained the role of the International Compensation Fund in the case of oil accident.", publisher = "Udruženje pravnika u privredi Srbije, Beograd", journal = "Pravo i privreda", title = "Specifičnosti imovinske odgovornosti za štetu od izlivanja/izbacivanja nafte sa broda u vodu, Some specific aspects of the civil liability for discharge and spill the oil from the ships", pages = "71-52", number = "10-12", volume = "49", url = "conv_2082" }
Janković, S.. (2012). Specifičnosti imovinske odgovornosti za štetu od izlivanja/izbacivanja nafte sa broda u vodu. in Pravo i privreda Udruženje pravnika u privredi Srbije, Beograd., 49(10-12), 52-71. conv_2082
Janković S. Specifičnosti imovinske odgovornosti za štetu od izlivanja/izbacivanja nafte sa broda u vodu. in Pravo i privreda. 2012;49(10-12):52-71. conv_2082 .
Janković, Svetislav, "Specifičnosti imovinske odgovornosti za štetu od izlivanja/izbacivanja nafte sa broda u vodu" in Pravo i privreda, 49, no. 10-12 (2012):52-71, conv_2082 .